In this episode of the Mistakes in the Making series, Kyler Wilson shared a personal and professional lesson about the critical importance of contracts in creative endeavors. Joined by Natalie Ruffino Wilson, the discussion delved into how a lack of legal agreements can jeopardize relationships, undermine trust, and threaten the success of creative projects. This candid conversation serves as a cautionary tale for filmmakers, writers, and artists navigating the complexities of collaboration.
Working Without Contracts: A Common Pitfall
The episode began with Kyler reflecting on his own experiences of working without contracts, even with close friends and colleagues. He acknowledged how easy it is to trust verbal agreements when working within a comfort zone, but warned that this approach often leads to complications.
Kyler shared his current collaboration with his best friend, Kyle Williams, as an example. Despite their strong relationship, the absence of a contract introduced unnecessary risks. Kyler emphasized that clear agreements are vital for maintaining professional boundaries and protecting creative efforts, regardless of the personal connection.
Early Creative Endeavors and Trust Issues
Kyler recounted an early mistake involving a script he had written. After a colleague expressed interest in his work, they approached him with an idea for a new script. Without a written agreement, Kyler began developing the concept, trusting their verbal understanding.
Dedicating several days to outlining and then drafting the script, Kyler poured his energy into the project. His colleague initially expressed enthusiasm, reinforcing Kyler’s belief that their arrangement was on solid ground. However, this trust was soon tested as feedback and demands for changes began to surface.
The Feedback Process: From Collaboration to Conflict
Kyler’s experience took a negative turn during the feedback stage. While the first round of changes seemed reasonable, subsequent requests became increasingly significant and, in Kyler’s view, detrimental to the story. When Kyler voiced concerns about these changes, his colleague dismissed them, creating a stalemate. Despite his reservations, Kyler incorporated most of the feedback, hoping to preserve the collaboration. However, one particular demand—to alter the script’s fundamental motivation and lore—proved too much. Kyler refused, sparking even more conflict.
A Creative Breakdown
After submitting the revised script, Kyler waited months for feedback, only to be met with another wave of requested changes. When he pushed back, his colleague decided to bring in another writer, effectively cutting Kyler out of the project. This was a significant blow to Kyler after months of dedicated work. It underscored the risks of informal agreements and highlighted the need for clear contracts to protect not only the work but also the professional relationships involved.
The Lessons Learned
Kyler’s experience offers valuable lessons for creatives:
Contracts Build Clarity: A contract serves as a written understanding of each party’s responsibilities, rights, and expectations. This clarity helps avoid misunderstandings and disputes down the line.
Trust Isn’t Enough: Even in collaborations with friends or trusted colleagues, a contract provides a professional framework that ensures fairness and accountability.
Feedback Needs Boundaries: Establishing how feedback will be given and implemented is crucial to maintaining the integrity of creative projects.
Protect Your Work: A contract safeguards your creative contributions, ensuring you’re credited and compensated appropriately.
Natalie’s Parallel Experience
Adding to Kyler’s narrative, Natalie shared her own story of being removed from a script she worked on without a contract. Like Kyler, she trusted the verbal agreement, only to be blindsided when circumstances changed. Her experience reinforced the episode’s core message: contracts aren’t just legal formalities—they’re tools for protecting both the work and the relationships involved in creative projects.
Resources for Filmmakers: Tools for Success
Kyler and Natalie acknowledged that many filmmakers and creatives avoid contracts because they seem intimidating or overly formal. To address this, they recommended several resources, including:
Contract Templates: Pre-made templates can simplify the process of drafting agreements.
AI Tools: Emerging technology can assist in customizing contracts to suit specific needs.
Legal Professionals: Consulting with an entertainment lawyer ensures your contract is robust and comprehensive.
These resources empower filmmakers to navigate the business side of creativity with confidence, ensuring their work is protected.
The Emotional Toll of Trust Issues
Beyond the logistical challenges, Kyler and Natalie touched on the emotional impact of trust issues in creative collaborations. The fallout from broken agreements can strain relationships, damage reputations, and discourage creatives from pursuing future projects. By establishing clear terms from the outset, contracts help preserve trust and foster healthier working relationships. They allow collaborators to focus on the creative process without the stress of ambiguity or potential conflict.
The Path Forward: Encouraging Best Practices
Kyler and Natalie concluded the episode by encouraging filmmakers to prioritize professionalism in every project, no matter the scale or participants. They emphasized that contracts aren’t barriers—they’re bridges that connect expectations and protect everyone involved. They also shared their contact information, inviting listeners to reach out with questions or for guidance. Their feature film, Best Laid Plans, stands as a testament to the lessons they’ve learned and the resilience they’ve built through their experiences.
Key Takeaways for Creatives
Always Use a Contract: No matter how small or informal a project may seem, a contract is essential for protecting your interests and relationships.
Set Clear Expectations: Define roles, responsibilities, and processes upfront to avoid misunderstandings later.
Be Proactive About Feedback: Establish a system for giving and implementing feedback that respects the creative vision.
Learn from Mistakes: Every setback is an opportunity to grow. Use past experiences to inform your approach to future projects.
Value Professionalism: Treat every collaboration with the same level of care and diligence, whether working with friends or industry professionals.
Final Thoughts: A Lesson in Resilience
Kyler Wilson’s story serves as a powerful reminder of the challenges and rewards of working in the creative industry. By sharing his mistakes, he offers invaluable guidance for filmmakers striving to balance trust, professionalism, and artistic integrity. Contracts may not eliminate every challenge, but they provide a foundation for healthier collaborations and more successful projects. As Kyler and Natalie demonstrate, protecting your work is not just about avoiding conflict—it’s about honoring the creativity and effort you bring to every endeavor.
Listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.